Unexplained lift at Ringstead
Returning from the Golden Gate to the Fort, the buoyant air continued out to sea, and I found myself up to 2800 feet, a half-mile offshore.
— Geoffrey Rutledge (1)
The article by Geoffrey Rutledge describes a flight starting at Fort Funston, the cliffs of which are only 200 feet high. He cruised the adjacent coastline of the San Francisco Bay Area. The article includes some theory that might help explain lifting air that this author encountered at Ringstead on the Dorset coast in England on August 8th, 2013. In addition, Ric Lee, a southern California motocross racer who took up hang gliding in his mid-20s, described a similar day at Fort Funston on 18th April 1977.
The Ringstead cliffs face south-west, but the lift on the cliffs on August 8th, 2013, was not great. The lift turned off completely a couple of times during the day, sending paragliders and one high-performance hang glider to the beach. It turned back on in late afternoon and it increased with enough of a south component to enable hang gliders and paragliders to fly the more south-facing cliffs east to Lulworth Cove and back.
Duncan and ZZ managed to get over 3000 ft ASL and on a couple of occasions were a mile or so back behind the ridge…
— From Wave? At Ringstead? by Duncan Edwards in Wessex Airmail, December 1999. (ZZ is Phil ‘ZZ’ Smith.)
A paraglider pilot describes the conditions on the day in August 2013 we experienced this phenomenon at Ringstead as “…from too windy, to too light, to too far off to the south and then too far off to the west…” (3)
During my flight, the wind veered (swung west). The lift on the cliff reduced while the wind increased to make it difficult for the slow-flying paragliders to penetrate.
My wrist altimeter showed me being 300 feet above the top of the cliff, and still climbing. I was pointed parallel to the cliff and just barely holding my position over the ground.
–Ric Lee (2)
Eventually (on this day at Ringstead) everybody else landed. About a half hour after I launched, orographic cloud began to form between where I was (over the cliff) and the top landing field (immediately behind the take-off hill). Some orographic cloud is visible in the distance in the accompanying photo taken earlier in the same flight.
Not wanting to be caught in cloud, I headed back towards the top landing field. It was then that I entered a slow but smooth climb over the shrub-covered slopes to the right (west) of the cliff. The orographic cloud in the vicinity dissipated and I continued to climb over the fields inland from the coastline. Eventually I reached 900 ft above my launch altitude, or about 1,300 MSL.
Everyone was at the same altitude. Flexi 2s were as high as Cumi 10s and Fledgelings. Everyone was at 2000 feet AGL/ASL, plus or minus a few feet.
–Ric Lee (2)
Wind lines on the sea in the photo indicate a surface wind somewhat west of south-west. When this photo was taken, I was flying directly into wind at more than 1000 feet MSL. (I was straight and level, but the wide angle of the camera lens might make it appear that I was in a left turn.) The wind there is clearly more like due west or even north of west. This wind shift with altitude seems more than the rule-of-thumb that (in the northern hemisphere) the wind veers about 20 degrees at 1000 ft compared to ground level.
The air was smooth and, flying at what felt to me the right speed for minimum sink rate (in a slow-flying type of hang glider) I was barely moving over the ground. Eventually, I pulled on extra speed and flew into sinking air just before arriving above the cutting of the road down to the beach. The road is out of view to the right of the photo, but the emergency bottom landing field (RAF Ringstead*) is the one containing the circle of tents.
* RAF Ringstead: Barely visible in this photo, at the left end of the emergency landing field (where the bushes and trees start — and partly cut by the bottom edge of the photo) is an earth mound that contains the reporting station for the radar aerials sited on these fields during World War 2.
Before we knew it, we were circling above the San Francisco Zoo. We were over flat ground, flying north. We decided to fly in formation, placing our shadows over the Great Highway.
–Ric Lee (2)
In the absence of either a zoo or a great highway at Ringstead, I then flew downwind and inland to the take-off hill, above which there was only sinking air at my height. That last observation precludes ridge lift as a possible cause of my climb (apart from the improbability of a small ridge providing lift to nearly ten times its height). After nearly an hour in the air I top-landed in the turbulence we always encounter behind the launch ridge in a west wind.
What caused the lift over these fields, which slope only slightly? One possibility is an atmospheric wave effect from Portland Island, directly off shore. (It is a much larger land mass than it appears in my photos.) However, on this day the wind was well off from Portland, so that seems an unlikely cause.
Maybe the 2009 article about the Funston convergence might shed some light:
…when the prevailing wind is a strong northwest condition, the southwest winds at Fort Funston may be the eddy caused by Point Reyes, a land mass protruding out to sea north of the Golden Gate.
— Geoffrey Rutledge (1)
Here is my diagrammatic interpretation of that, based on the assumption that the land roughness slows the wind more than does the smoother sea, which causes the wind direction to swing in accord with the grey wind arrows:
And here is my equivalent interpretation of the Ringstead convergence:
It strikes me that a minor change either in the basic wind direction or thermal effects from the solar heating of the land (at Point Reyes in the first case and at Portland and Weymouth in the second) could cause rapid and major changes down-wind, affecting flying conditions at these coastal flying sites.
Many theories were offered, but the most widely accepted one was the convergence of a cold, stable NE wind meeting a warm, unstable NW. If you examine a map of the San Francisco peninsula, you will see the possibilities for such a sheer.
–Ric Lee (2)
Nevertheless, the smoothness of the air in that lift zone at Ringstead is more characteristic of wave than of convergence.
Overview of Ringstead (a sight-seeing guide, not a flying site guide)
1. Geoffrey Rutledge, Flying the Shear at Funston, May 2009 edition of Hang Gliding & Paragliding (see under External link later on this page)
2. Ric Lee describing the Fort Funston sheer in Hang Gliding, July 1977. (By 1977, some flex-wing hang gliders still bore a somewhat kite-shaped look, but many were roughly verging on the shapes they have nowadays.)
3. Grant Oseland, Eye in the Sky, Wessex Hang Gliding and Paragliding Club, August 8th 2013
Flying the Shear at Funston by Geoffrey Rutledge, in the May 2009 edition of Hang Gliding & Paragliding